Appel, P.W.U., Dyikanova, C., Esengulova, N. & Tagaeva, A. 2004:
Baseline survey of artisanal and small-scale mining and Teaching seminars for small scale miners in Kyrgyz Republic 2003.
Danmarks og Grønlands Geologiske Undersøgelse Rapport 2004/11, 28 pp.
Hjemtag (download) pdf-filen
Hvis du vil udskrive, så brug venligst pdf-filen
Kræver en pdf-læser,
G E U S
Recommendations of small-scale miners after teaching seminars in Eki-Naryn and
Videoconference on distance learning courses for small-scale miners. Bishkek,
October 14, 2003.
Salkyn Niyazova, small-scale miner, Sary-jaz area, Issyk-Kul oblast................... 24
Abdykadyr Abdrahmanov, small-scale miner, At-Bashy area, Naryn oblast......... 24
Nurlan Orozbaev, small-scale miner, Naryn oblast. ............................................. 25
Bakas Gaparov, small-scale miner, Soh area, Batken oblast............................... 25
Farhad Satimov, small-scale miner, Chatkal area, Jalal-Abad oblast................... 25
Usenbek Choponov, geologist, small-scale miner, Naryn oblast.......................... 26
G E U S
G E U S
1. In 1994 World Bank published a Review of the Mining Sector in Kyrgyz Republic. This
was followed up by an other investigation in last quarter of 2000, which was published
in September 2002. During the autumn 2002 World Bank decided to conduct a baseline
survey of artisanal and small-scale mining in Kyrgyz Republic and to produce distance
learning courses on this topic. Trust funds from the Danish Ministry of Foreign Affairs
financed this survey. It was carried out by a consultant from the Geological Survey of
Denmark and Greenland (GEUS), Copenhagen, Denmark. GEUS subcontracted part of
the work to Community Business Forum (CBF), an NGO enterprise based in Bishkek.
During the course of this Study, many discussions were conducted with government of-
ficials, private companies, and members of civil society (see list in Annex 1).
2. Small-scale mining has been carried out in the Kyrgyz Republic since ancient times.
During the Soviet period small scale mining took place in organised legal co-operatives
in the 1930's and 1940's. After the Second World War the number of small-scale min-
ers decreased to almost nil. After the collapse of the Soviet Union thousands of Kyrgyz
lost their jobs in towns as well as in the countryside. One of the few opportunities was
to go to the mountains and seek gold. That was literally done by thousands of people.
There is no efficient registration of small-scale miners, so it is difficult to assess how
many miners there are. Based on our study and interviews with local officials a conser-
vative estimate will be more than 5500 small-scale miners and the number are in-
creasing every year.
3. The laws and regulations for small-scale miners are contradictory and conflicting infor-
mation about the content and conditions of the Regulation for small-scale miners are
frequent. Even officials in high positions do not know the rules. Local authorities
throughout the country know very little about the regulations and appear to be indiffer-
ent the small-scale miners. Placer gold small-scale mining is allowed, but hard rock
mining is forbidden. According to the law, all gold mined by small-scale miners should
be sold to legalised gold receipt desks. However, there are no such desks in the Kyrgyz
Republic. It is therefore not possible for any small-scale miner to sell their product le-
4. Two types of small-scale mining are carried out. Hard rock and placer gold mining. The
latter is most widespread whereas the former being slightly more difficult appears to be
more profitable. There is a wide range of how much gold each small-scale miner re-
cover per year. A large group of small-scale miners recovers less than 60 grams per
year, but there are many miners who recover between 60 and 200 gram per year. In
some areas gold nuggets up to 130 gram are recovered. Nuggets fetch very high prices
on the world market (two to three times' normal gold price). However, small-scale min-
ers finding gold nuggets in Kyrgyz Republic only get per gram gold price. It is sug-
gested that an outlet for gold nuggets be established. Small-scale miners sometimes
find platinum and reportedly also osmium. In most cases no gold dealers will buy plati-
num or osmium. World market price for platinum is 20 USD per gram and for osmium
around 75 USD per gram compared with the current gold price of 11.5 USD per gram. It
would thus be an extra income if the small-scale miners could sell these precious met-
5. Gold recovered by small-scale miners is sold to illegal gold dealers. Some are Kyrgyz,
many are from Uzbekistan and few are from China. The Chinese dealers often buy gold
through an intermediary. In order to control the gold market the Kyrgyz government
asked the government owned gold mining company Kyrgyzaltyn to establish offices to
buy gold from small-scale miners. Kyrgyzaltyn established two offices one in Naryn and
another in Chatkal areas. These offices started early 2002 but were closed down after
about one year because only few small-scale miners would sell gold to them. The price
offered by Kyrgyzaltyn was too low and the distance to travel for the small-scale miners
to the shops was too long. The price offered by the illegal gold dealers varies consid-
G E U S
erably from district to district and from villages to district centres. The most quoted price
is between 300 and 430 som pr. gram (7 to 10 USD). In remote areas prices as low as
250 som are reported. Only few gold buyers pay more than 430 som per gram. One of
the advantages for small-scale miners to sell gold to illegal gold dealers is that dealers
come and buy at the mining sites. They furthermore often supply necessary equipment
and possibly also mercury to the small-scale miners. This save the small-scale miners
long travel times to buy these items.
6. Small-scale gold mining is a major source of income in some areas and an additional
income in others. In Batken area the average working period by small-scale miners is 4
to 5 months per year. In Chatkal a large group of miners work between 1 and 3 months
whereas another large group work 10 to 12 months per year. In Naryn the majority of
miners work 4 to 6 months, but many also work the year around. An estimated 5500
small-scale miners work in the investigated areas.
7. With very few exceptions small-scale mining is only carried out by men.
8. Only a very small proportion of small-scale miners have a certificate or patent to carry
out their small scale mining. The price for a certificate is 30 som (0.75 USD) per year
although there is some confusion as to the exact figure. Almost all small-scale miners
are very interested in having their work legalised by obtaining a license. It is apparently
often difficult for them to get a license. Many local district administrations do not support
small-scale mining and are reluctant or do not know how to issue licenses. A license for
a small-scale miner would stop the necessity for him to bribe local police, which report-
edly often is required.
9. A larger part of small-scale miners in Batken, Naryn and Chatkal areas are very inter-
ested in uniting into larger groups of 15 to 20 people provided they could get the nec-
essary equipment. It will require funding to purchase this equipment and the present
estimate from the small-scale miners is that they would need access to bulldozers and
excavators and then on the order of 7.000 USD to buy pumps, sluices, proper clothing
10. A majority of the small-scale miners have expressed strong interest for training pro-
grams. They need on site training on how to increase the recovery of gold, and also
classroom training on health hazards and gaining basic knowledge of geology. They
also find it very useful to receive literature describing new techniques. A future project
should comprise training of a number of local experts who then could teach the small
scale miners throughout the country.
11. There are considerable health hazards for the small-scale miners, but most of these
can be avoided by inexpensive means. Crushing gold-bearing quartz-veins yields
quartz dust, which, if inhaled, can give silicosis. Masks, which can be bought from the
military for 50 som (just over one dollar), can protect the miners against dust. Many
miners and gold dealers use nitric acid to recover gold. This process develops exceed-
ingly toxic fumes of nitrogen dioxide. If inhaled, even in very small quantities, it disturbs
the immune system of the lungs, gives lung oedema and may cause death. This can be
avoided by carrying out the process in open air only away from inhabited areas. A
handout describing the health problems by using nitric acid and how to use the method
properly has been made. The Swiss Red Cross is presently distributing the handout to
village nurses in Naryn oblast. No means for distributing these handouts to other parts
of Kyrgyz Republic have been found yet.
12. Small-scale miners working in hard rock and placer deposits often dig tunnels up to 50
m long. Roof and walls are not supported and frequently cave in resulting in injuries,
which sometimes are fatal. Timber is expensive in Kyrgyz Republic and not readily
available, so other means of supporting material must be used. Experts from Institute of
Physics and Mechanics of Rocks based in Bishkek will hopefully find solutions to this
13. Mercury is used by more than 50 % of the small-scale miners and most of the gold
dealers to recover gold by the so-called amalgamation process. Mercury is highly toxic
and give permanent brain damage and possibly even death. During amalgamation
mercury evaporates and enters the atmosphere. From there it enters the drainage
G E U S
system where it is transformed to an even more toxic compound methylated mercury.
The mercury finally enters the food chain. All over the world amalgamation has caused
extensive pollution of the environment and major health problems. The retort, a simple
and inexpensive device, recycles the mercury and thus saves money for small-scale
miners and protects environment and health. This can be made out of ordinary water-
pipes available in Bishkek for less than 20 USD per retort, However, use of mercury is
prohibited in Kyrgyz Republic and it is not allowed to produce or use the retort. It is
strongly recommended to change the law and allow use of mercury. Governments in
South America, Africa and Southeast Asia have tried to stop amalgamation by prohib-
iting use of mercury, but without any success. The Kyrgyz Minister of Health suggested
to establish round table talks with the World Bank and the appropriate ministries in or-
der to try and modify the law so amalgamation will be legalised.
14. Small-scale mining causes degradation of land surface. The problem in hard rock min-
ing is minor. Placer gold mining results in many small holes and tunnels dug in the riv-
erbanks. Most of these features will be eroded away by next flooding of the rivers. Any
remaining features are fairly minor, especially compared with the large piles of rusty
machinery left on the river banks from large scale placer gold mining carried out during
15. There are considerable frictions between hard rock small-scale miners and state owned
company Kyrgyzaltyn. Small-scale miners working near Solton-sary and Makmal mines
have been chased away, sometimes using pretty ruthless by security guards with dogs.
Small-scale miners mine small gold-bearing quartz-veins, which never will be profitable
for Kyrgyzaltyn. It should be possible for Kyrgyzaltyn and small-scale miners to work
peacefully side by side. Small-scale miners have suggested that they could mine the
vaste dumps from the Kyrgyzaltyn mines without interfering with the ongoing industrial
mining operations. These suggestions make sense; unfortunately Kyrgyzaltyn has re-
jected the suggestion.
G E U S
Recommendations of small-scale miners after
teaching seminars in Eki-Naryn and Bishkek
October 9 a teaching seminar was held in the village of Eki-Naryn in central Kyrgyz Repub-
lic with 27 small-scale miners participating. October 14 and 15 a teaching seminar was held
in Bishkek for 12 small scale miners from different parts of the country. In the Bishkek
seminar participants from relevant ministries also participated. For further details see
chapter on Teaching Seminars. This chapter is a brief outline of the recommendations from
the small-scale miners and other participants of the teaching seminars.
Negotiations with the Kyrgyz government on the following issues should be initiated. The
Kyrgyz law on natural resources comprising the regulations on individual small-scale min-
ers should be modified. Some of the many issues in the law, which need to be changed,
are the following. Hard rock small-scale mining should be legalised. The monopoly of the
state owned company Kyrgyzaltyn of buying gold including gold nuggets should be lifted,
and licensed gold dealers should be allowed to operate throughout the country. Certificate
for small-scale miners should not cost more than 30 som (~0.7 USD).
If and when the Regulations on individual small-scale miners are changed then local
authorities throughout the country should be prompted to support small-scale miners in
their wish to get registered. Local authorities should also be encouraged to keep closer
track on small-scale miners e.g. by registering accidents and casualties during their mining
operations. The local authorities should realise that: Small-scale gold mining provides jobs
in remote mountain villages and thus reduces migration of able-bodied people to urban
Government owned Kyrgysaltyn should be encouraged to let small-scale miners work near
their operating mines and possibly even working on waste dumps from the mining opera-
Round table discussions with the Ministry of Health and other relevant ministries should be
carried out in order to modify the present laws and regulations forbidding use of mercury
and nitric acid. At the same token measures should be taken to assure that small-scale
miners and gold dealers are taught how to use nitric acid and mercury in a way which re-
duces the health risks and the risk of impact on the environment. If and when these laws
and regulations have been modified then a campaign among small-scale miners should be
carried out to advocate the use of retorts, which recycle mercury used during gold extrac-
Training of small-scale miners is a very important issue. Presently everybody without a job
may go out and start small-scale mining. It does take some skill and a good deal of educa-
tion in order to maximise the recovery of gold and other precious metals such as platinum.
It is recommended to carry out training courses for small-scale miners in all regions of
Kyrgyz Republic where small-scale mining takes place. The training courses should be on
site with a combination of practical instruction on how to recover gold and class room
teaching in health risks and basic knowledge of geology so the small-scale miners can rec-
ognise the valuable minerals and metals they recover from their activities.
G E U S
In 1993 World Bank carried out an investigation of mining in Kyrgyz Republic. This was
followed up by an other investigation in last quarter of 2000, which was published in Sep-
tember 2002. During the autumn 2002 World Bank decided to conduct a baseline survey of
artisanal and small-scale mining in Kyrgyz Republic and to produce distance learning
courses on this topic. Trust funds from the Danish Ministry of Foreign Affairs financed this
survey. It was carried out by a consultant from the Geological Survey of Denmark and
Greenland (GEUS), Copenhagen, Denmark. GEUS subcontracted part of the work to
Community Business Forum (CBF), an NGO enterprise based in Bishkek.
Small-scale mining in this report is defined as mining carried out by a small group of people
generally less than five using no mechanical equipment. In this definition it is synonymous
with artisanal mining. Throughout this report the term small-scale mining will be used.
Small-scale mining has been carried out in Kyrgyz Republic for several thousand years.
During the early days of the Soviet Union that is in the 1930's and 1940's small-scale min-
ing was carried out by large organised groups. After the Second World War the number of
small-scale miners decreased considerably. The communist system provided jobs for eve-
rybody, and it was thus not necessary to resort to small-scale mining.
After the collapse of the Soviet Union many of the people of Kyrgyz Republic were sud-
denly left without jobs. In the countryside the collective farms ceased working. In the
smaller and bigger towns factories closed down. Apart from limited often horse-powered
agriculture and cattle breeding very few jobs remained. One of the few opportunities for the
population was to go to the mountains and seek gold. That was literally done by thousands
of people, but legislation has not made life easy for them. On the contrary the set of laws
for small-scale miners and the ignorance of the local authorities has forced the small-scale
miners to carry out their work illegally. It is presently not even possible for small-scale min-
ers to sell their gold anywhere in the Kyrgyz Republic to legal gold buyers. Small-scale gold
mining should be supported by the Kyrgyz Government and local authorities, since it pro-
vides jobs in remote mountain villages and thus reduces migration of able-bodied people to
urban areas. Gold was the main target for the small-scale miners, but limited small-scale
mining of coal in the vicinity of existing coalmines took place. This report describes exclu-
sively small-scale mining for gold.
The World Bank consultant initiated the study during his first visit to Kyrgyz Republic from
late May to mid June 2003. During the initial in country visit the consultant liased closely
with relevant government officials, private groups, civil society, academics, and the Bank's
resident mission (see list of people met in Annex 1). This was followed by field visits to se-
lected small-scale mining in Naryn and Chatkal areas of central and western Kyrgyz Re-
public (see map Fig. 1).
During the months July and August CBF visited three major small-scale mining areas and
asked 350 small-scale miners a series of questions. Part of the questions was technical
and part of the questions socio-economic. CBF also questioned officials and gold dealers in
the same areas. A detailed description of the results of these investigations is seen in An-
Follow up was made during a second visit from late September to mid October 2003. Dur-
ing this mission several small-scale mining sites were visited in Sary-Jaz and Naryn areas
of eastern and central Kyrgyz Republic (see Annex 3 for details on technical investiga-
tions). A one-day teaching seminar was held in the village of Eki-Naryn 9 October. During
the field visits to Sary-Jaz, Naryn and Chatkal areas small-scale miners were invited to
participate in a two day teaching seminar in Bishkek to be held 14 and 15 October. The
G E U S
invited small-scale miners were also invited to participate in a distant learning course in the
World Bank office in Bishkek.
Figure 1. Map of Kyrgyz Republic showing areas of field investigations and areas investi-
gated by questionnaires
Main gold belt of Kyrgyz
Kumtor gold mine
Makmal gold mine
of small scale mining
G E U S
History of gold mining in Kyrgyz Republic
Gold mining in Kyrgyz Republic has a long story. The earliest records show that placer
mining took place in the second millennium BC in the lower parts of the Chatkal river. Chi-
nese sources show that placer gold mining took place 751 AD in the mountains around
Fergana valley. Arabic manuscripts from 10th and 11th century tell that gold was mined in
Krakhanid State (present Kyrgyzstan), mainly in Fergana valley.
The techniques used were standard placer mining techniques. Amalgamation already took
place in ancient times as testified by finds of vessels in which miners kept the mercury as
described in sources from 943 A. D. Sheepskin was also used in those days. The Greek
myth of Jason fetching the golden skin refers to the sheep skin method. A sheepskin is
placed in a fast running stream; gold particles tumbling down through the stream get caught
in the sheepskin. After some time the sheepskin is dried and either burned or the gold is
shaken out of the skin. This method is used even today in remote areas such as Sary-jaz!
Sometimes old rugs are used instead of sheepskin.
During the Soviet period small scale mining was carried by state organisations such as
"Sredazolotorazvedka". By the end of 1930's the total number of legal gold miners
amounted to 2000 people. At that time small-scale miners were organised into co-
operatives from 40 and more members, but at each placer gold deposits they have been
working in smaller brigades from 3-5 people, which was convenient for small-scale mining
activities. The most advantageous managed to mine 1 gram of gold per day. Gold washing
was carried out in wooden washing drums and in wooden sluices without any mechanical
support. Amalgamation to recover gold from concentrate was widely used.
"Sredazolotorazvedka" purchased the gold mined by small-scale miners.
After the second World War small scale mining decreased.
G E U S
Small-scale mining takes place in most part of the Kyrgyz Republic. The present study was
concentrated in the areas shown on Fig. 1. In the West is Chatkal area, in the central part
Naryn area in South Batken area and in the extreme east the Sary-Jaz area. In Chatkal and
Naryn areas thousands of small-scale miners work. In Sary-jaz small-scale mining has
started within the last couple of years (Fig. 2 and 3). There are less than 100 small-scale
miners, but the number is rapidly increasing. In the Batken area small-scale mining is also
fairly new, but there are already several hundred small-scale miners.
During the consultant's two missions the Chatkal, Naryn and Sary-jaz areas of western,
central and eastern Kyrgyz Republic were visited. Through local contacts established by
CBF appropriate small scale mining sites were chosen for visits. In Chatkal meetings were
held with local officials. They were very interested in the WB project and would support it as
far as resources allowed. They estimated about 2000 active small-scale miners in the
Chatkal area, of which 92 are registered. A certificate costs 30 som (0.70 USD) for one
year. We were told us that the state owned gold mining company Kyrgyzaltyn has sug-
gested to the government that a patent should cost 130 som per month. This higher fee for
a certificate would discourage artisanal miners from registering with the government and
inhibit further programs to provide them with assistance.
Two types of small-scale mining are carried out in Kyrgyz Republic, hard rock mining and
placer gold mining. A detailed technical description is provided in Annex 3. Hard rock min-
ing where gold-bearing quartz veins are mined by digging tunnels into the mountains is
apparently the most profitable. The tunnels sometimes collapse resulting in severe, some-
times fatal accidents. The miners collect only rock chips with visible gold. These chips are
carried back to the villages and crushed. After crushing the heavy minerals and gold are
separated by gravitation. The crushing produce quartz dust which may cause silicosis. The
concentrate is the frequently treated with boiling nitric acid. This is done in small confined
yards often with plenty of children playing nearby. This process yields very pure gold. Boil-
ing nitric acid reacting with heavy minerals produce exceedingly toxic fumes of nitrogen
dioxide which even in trace amounts disturb the immune system of the lungs, give lung
oedema and may cause death. For further details see chapter on health.
Placer gold mining takes place in recent and sub-recent river gravel. Holes a couple of
meters in diameter and a couple of meters deep are dug into the riverbanks (Fig. 3). Some-
times, as seen in Chatkal tunnels are dug into unconsolidated gravel in order to trace gold-
bearing strata. The tunnels often cave in. Injuries are frequent. The gold-bearing gravel is
Figure 2. En route to Sary-Jaz
Figure 3. Small scale miner in Sary-Jaz
G E U S
sieved and the coarse grained gold is recovered in a sluice (Fig. 4). In some areas the
small-scale miners add a copper plate coated by mercury at the end of the sluice in order to
catch finer grained gold. Instead of the mercury coated copper plate many small-scale min-
ers use amalgamation. They add mercury to the heavy mineral concentrate from the sluice.
Gold is dissolved in the mercury. The miners subsequently burn off the mercury and the
gold is recovered. This is a very toxic process. One miner told that he used a mask to pro-
tect himself against the mercury vapour. This will save him during the process of amalga-
mation, but his wife, children and him will gradually be poisoned when the mercury enters
the drainage system. For further details see chapter on health.
Suggestions of improvement
Several means of improving the recovery of gold and reduction of health hazards and im-
pact on the environmental were discussed with the small-scale miners at the mining sites
and during the training courses held in Naryn and Bishkek.
· Hard rock miners should crush all mined rock chips at the mining site and not only go
for chips with visible gold. Thereby they would recover more gold and carry less weight
· They should wear dust masks during crushing. Dust masks can be bought from the
military for 50 som (1.1 USD).
· Acid treatment should be carried out in open fields away from villages and with no chil-
dren playing around nearby.
· Placer gold miners can probably increase their recovery by 30 to 40%. Investigation
carried out by Kyrgyz geologists showed that 30 to 40% of the gold in many placer de-
posits occur as gold dust. This fine-grained gold will be flushed out of sluices back into
the rivers. By using more sieves, proper gold pans and probably amalgamation they
should be able to recover a good deal of the fine-grained gold. Amalgamation can be
done quite safely by using a retort. This is an inexpensive devise recommended by
UNIDO. It is constructed by non galvanised ordinary water pipes. The retort recycles
the mercury whereby the small-scale miners does not harm the environment and saves
money on mercury.
Figure 4. Small scale miner
digging into loose gravel
Figure 5. Sieve and sluice
G E U S
During the months of July and August 350 questionnaires were given to small-scale miners,
27 to gold buyers and 26 to local authorities in three areas. Batken in South, Naryn in cen-
tral and Chatkal in East Kyrgyzstan. This chapter provides a summary of the results. A de-
tailed account is seen in Annex 2.
On the whole, about 5500 people are working in the surveyed gold mining areas. Hard rock
deposits are considered the most economically profitable, but most miners work in placer
Mining period varies from one province to the next. Most of the gold mining in Naryn oblast
is carried out about 6-7 months in a year during the warm seasons, but many do work the
whole year. In Chatkal ant Batken climatic conditions allow people to mine the whole year.
The amount of gold recovered by each miner varies considerably. The majority of the min-
ers recover less than 60 gram of gold per year. A fairly large group recover up to 200 gram
per year and only very few recover more than 200 gram.
The price of gold varies considerably from one part of the country to the next and with the
distance from the district centres. Most miners get 300 to 400 som per gram (9 to 10 USD).
A large proportion of miners use mercury and nitric acids. Very few of them are aware of
the dangers involved by using these chemicals.
Other serious health risks are injuries and casualties from caving in of tunnels dug in hard
rock and river gravel.
Local administration does not pay much attention to the accidents happening in small-scale
mining, neither do they do much to encourage the small scale miners to obtain licence or
Small-scale gold mining is generally unhealthy because feet and hands are always in cold
mountain water. Measures to reduce climate conditioned risk:
Buying special clothes to protect hands and feet of small-scale miners from cold water.
They do use rubber boots, but they are often full of holes.
Buying warm, waterproof tents.
Support establishment of co-operatives, which will be able to obtain loans, invest them
(buying technical equipment, tractors, excavators, etc.) and mine more gold. But, im-
perfection of taxation system will not give real steps to develop larger mining co-
Developments of a better health care system in the remote areas.
Problems of village youth
According to many sociologist youth poverty is becoming a significant and increasing
problem. Youth unemployment in villages raises many worries, as unemployed youth
is socially isolated, they often become drug-users and get involved in crime. At present
more than 20 thousand young people do not study or work and remain dependent on
G E U S
There are several laws and regulations concerning small-scale miners. They are partly
contradictive and they need to be modified. The account below is by no means compre-
hensive. This is partly due to the fact that we received quite contradictory information from
different parties involved.
The legislative act, regulating the use of natural recourses and small-scale gold mining is
the Law on natural resources of the Kyrgyz Republic enacted in 1997.
It was supplemented by the Regulation of the order of licensing of use of natural resources,
approved by the Resolution of the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic of 14.06.2000 No.
Law on Precious Stones and Precious Metals of Kyrgyz Republic; Land Code of KR; Taxa-
tion Code; Temporary Regulation (#224) on Small-scale Gold Mining of Kyrgyz Republic of
10/05/2001 and few other standard acts, regulating mining, production and safe keeping
issues of precious stones.
In 2001 Resolution of 10.05.2001 No. 224 of the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic ap-
proved Temporary Regulation on individual small-scale gold mining on the territory of the
Kyrgyz Republic. In accordance with this Regulation individual small scale gold mining was
legalised but with many restrictions such as:
· Small-scale mining may be carried out using mechanical equipment, but not exceeding
· Sluice capacity must not exceed 1 cubic meter per hour.
· Tunnelling is prohibited.
· Small-scale mining must not cause destruction of the landscape.
· Small-scale mining must only be carried out in placer deposits. Hard rock small-scale
mining is prohibited.
· Use of any chemicals such as cyaniding and amalgamation is prohibited.
· The small-scale miners must take safety measures.
· Gold recovered must only be sold to gold receipt desks legalised by the Government.
A simplified order of registration (certificate) of small-scale gold miners in village commit-
tees was introduced for a very symbolic price of 30 som (0.70 USD) per year. However,
recent inquiries at the Prime Ministers office revealed that in addition to the 30 som per
year, 100 som (2.5 USD) should be paid per month to local administration. However, ac-
cording to the Temporary Regulations: A small-scale miner who properly maintain main
conditions of mining and selling gold, foreseen by the above Regulation, then duration of
the Certificate on small-scale mining would be prolonged by all means and without any
The Temporary Regulation contradicts the Law on Mineral Resources and it is expected to
be valid until adoption of amendments into the Law.
Unfortunately, the Temporary Regulation does not allow for the settling of conflicts:
- Parcels for small-scale gold mining are not being reserved by a governmental li-
censing body, and a new license can be issued to them, and small-scale gold min-
ers will be thrown away from the site of their business.
- The Regulation does not regulate legal relationships between small-scale gold min-
ers, using one and the same object for gold mining.
- The Regulation does not legalise work of buyers of gold and assigns to sell placer
gold to Governmental State Gold Receipt Desks run by Kyrgyzaltyn.
G E U S
A later Law on Mineral Resources of Kyrgyz Republic (with amendments and changes
signed by the President Akaev in 04/02/2002) is the main legislative act regulating issues
on use of minerals, including individual gold mining. It is not clear how this law treat the
problems for small-scale miners.
By Enactment #882 issued by the Kyrgyz Government on 26
of December 2002 small-
scale mining in placer gold deposits is enlisted as type of enterprise undertaken by indi-
viduals on patent basis.
A committee on Income under the Ministry of Finances of Kyrgyz Republic was to set
amount of payment for a patent (certificate), considering income of small-scale miner got
from gold mining. Also there was to be taken into account deductions, which were made
from income earned according to Taxation Code. But as monitoring of small-scale gold
mining, which was organised in 2003 by "Avista" Company on the TACIS Program, this
patent system has not been implemented in areas where small-scale miners work.
Considering 3-year experience of practising Temporary regulation it is necessary to make
amendments and changes to its new edition, and also to introduce lower taxes for small-
scale mining on legal basis.
1. To exclude that point saying that Kyrgyzaltyn has a monopoly right in opening gold
receipt desks, so any juridical person, who has enough funds, could open gold re-
ceipt desk registering it.
2. To legalise small-scale mining in small hard rock deposits, and waste dumps left by
large-scale enterprises, which are not of interest for big mining enterprises and are
not included to the State Balance.
3. Small-scale miners should be allowed to use chemicals such as nitric acid and re-
torts provided they have passed a training course on how to handle these methods
without risking their health and damaging the environment.
4. Taxes and other dues should be paid by gold receipt desks; their rates should be
minimum, allowing gold receipt desks to set prices that are close to black market
5. Another suggestion is that foreign tourists could practice small-scale mining. It
would be an attractive type of tourism as seen in several other countries e.g. Fin-
G E U S
The baseline study has revealed a number of serious health problems for small-scale min-
ers described in detail in Annex 3.
1. During hard rock and placer gold mining tunnels are often dug into mountains or
banks of the rivers. These tunnels are often up to 50 meter long and in some areas
there are networks of tunnels. Neither roof nor walls are supported in the tunnels.
The lack of support result in frequent caving in whereby the miners have injuries,
which are sometimes fatal.
2. Crushing of gold bearing quartz-veins yield dust of quartz, which may result in sili-
3. Acid treatment is a process where boiling nitric acid dissolves sulphides in heavy
sand from the sluices, yielding a very pure concentrate of gold. It is mostly carried
out in small confined yards. The process produce exceedingly toxic fumes of nitro-
gen dioxide, which even in trace amounts, disturb the immune system of the lungs,
give lung oedema and may cause death.
4. Mercury is used by many small-scale miners for amalgamation. This method was
used in the 1940's during the Soviet period, and today more than 60 % of the placer
gold miners use mercury. The method is used to recover very fine-grained gold
from concentrates from hard rock as well as placer gold mining. During the process
the mercury evaporates and is lost to the environment. Some of it may enter di-
rectly into the lungs of the small-scale miners. The remaining mercury end up in the
drainage system where it enters the food chain either as metallic mercury or as the
even more toxic methylated mercury. Poisoning by metallic and methylated mer-
cury may result in irreversible damage of the nervous system, kidney problems and
brain damage, tunnel vision, permanent muscular tremors. Some of the symptoms
are blue gums, impairment of hearing, speech and gait, problems with the immune
defence system and erithism, often phycho-pathological.
Figure 6. Toxic fumes of nitrogen
Figure 7. Retort for recycling of mer-
cury in amalgamation
G E U S
Suggestions to reduce health problems
1. Experts in rock mechanics from the Institute of Physics and Mechanics of rocks based
in Bishkek will hopefully provide inexpensive solutions to support roof and walls in the
2. The Kyrgyz military sell dust-preventing masks for 50 som (~1.1 USD). These masks
give sufficient protection against the quartz dust. Furthermore the small-scale miners
should be instructed not to crush rocks when children are around.
The risk of serious health problems caused by nitrogen dioxide during acid treatment
can fairly easily be reduced significantly. If the process is carried out in open field a few
hundred meters from the villages with no children and other people standing by and the
person carrying out the process take care that the wind is blowing away from him then
there will be virtually be no problems. Swiss Red Cross has an extensive network of
village nurses in Naryn oblast. The Red Cross will use this network for distribution of
handouts describing the dangers and the way out when using nitric acid and also how
to prevent silicosis during crushing rocks. Swiss Red Cross is presently distributing
these handouts. Mr. Mitalip M. Mamytov, Minister of Health will also try to help to dis-
tribute the information on the dangers of using nitric acid and how to use it safely to
other parts of Kyrgyz Republic.
Use of mercury in the Kyrgyz Republic is strictly prohibited. Nevertheless do many
small-scale miners in most parts of the country use it. Many governments in South
America, Africa and East Asia have prohibited the use of mercury for amalgamation.
None of these governments have been successful. Small-scale miners still go on using
mercury, because it is their only way out of poverty. The number of small-scale miners
all over the World using mercury is increasing every year. World Bank and United Na-
tions Industrial Organisation (UNIDO) have a number of projects aimed at reducing the
health hazards and environmental impact of amalgamation. A very simple solution is
introduction of a retort. This is an inexpensive devise made of ordinary non-galvanised
water pipes, which are available in most parts of the World. A detailed technical de-
scription of the retort is presented in Annex 3. The retort recycles more than 90% of the
mercury used for amalgamation. This has two obvious advantages for the small-scale
miners and for society. The small-scale miners save money on buying mercury and
they do not harm the environment. The retort can be produced in Bishkek at a price of
less than 20 USD. However, it is forbidden according to Kyrgyz law to produce devices,
which are meant to be used when working with mercury. We had a meeting with Mitalip
M. Mamytov, Minister of Health. He asked us to find out according to which law it is for-
bidden to produce retorts. When that was established he suggested World Bank and
the appropriate ministries made round table discussions and try to find a way to legalise
amalgamation for small-scale miners. Chris Lovelace was informed and would go
ahead as soon as he received a detailed description from the consultant and task man-
G E U S
Two environmental problems have been encountered during this mission. Release of mer-
cury to the environment and destruction of the land surface as a result of diggings.
Mercury is released to the environment by small-scale miners by two processes. Mercury
coated copper plates are sometimes placed at the end of the sluices in order to catch small
gold grains. The river water flushes constantly over the mercury coating and small amounts
of mercury will be washed into the stream. A much more dramatic mercury impact is, how-
ever, caused by amalgamation. This process releases large amounts of mercury directly
into the atmosphere and from there it enters the drainage system and the food chain.
Amalgamation was also used in the Soviet period. At that time it was legal and much mer-
cury was washed into the streams and is now partly buried under sand and clay as so-
called metallic hot spots. With renewed activity of placer gold mining digging sand and
gravel in and around these hot spots will reactivate the mercury which will start travelling in
the drainage system. It is fairly easy to reduce the impact on the environment of amalga-
mation by using the retort as described in the health section and in Annex 3.
The other environmental problem encountered is land destruction during digging of holes
and tunnels into mountains and riverbanks. In the Chatkal region many holes in the river-
banks have indeed been observed. However many of these diggings will be wiped out by
the next flooding of the river. Any remaining features are minor compared to much larger
holes and large piles of rusty equipment from large scale industrial placer gold mining car-
ried out during the Soviet period. It is obviously difficult to persuade the present small-scale
miners to reclaim the ground where they work when they look at the ground next to their
area and see mass destruction of the land surface by previous mining activity.
G E U S
Gold market considerations
The government owned company Kyrgyzaltyn has complete monopoly on buying gold in
the Kyrgyz Republic. The company runs several gold mines in the country. After collapse of
the Soviet Union small-scale gold mining increased and the amount of gold produced with-
out government control likewise. The gold produced by small-scale miners was sold to ille-
gal gold buyers. In order to gain control of the gold produced by small-scale miners the
Kyrgyz government asked Kyrgyzaltyn to establish gold receiving desks where the small-
scale miners could trade in their gold. Kyrgyzaltyn subsequently established two shops one
in Naryn and one in Chatkal, two areas where thousands of small-scale miners were active.
The shops were not a success and were closed down within one year. There were two rea-
sons for the failure. One reason, according to the small-scale mines, was that the price
offered from Kyrgyzaltyn was too low. Another reason is related to the distance to the gold
shop. With only two shops in the whole country it is a long travel for small-scale miners to
get to the shops. Illegal gold buyers offered to buy gold at the mining site, they often also
supplied necessary equipment for small-scale miners, possibly also mercury used by many
The present situation is then: Kyrgyzaltyn has still monopoly to buy gold, but a law obedient
small-scale miner has no legal place where to go and sell his gold! His only way out is to
sell to illegal gold buyers.
The price offered by the illegal gold dealers depends on the distance from district centres.
In Naryn, district centre of Naryn oblast the price for gold is 430 som (~10 USD) per gram.
In the village Eki-Naryn a one and a half-hours drive from Naryn the price of gold has de-
creased to 300 to 350 som (7 to 8 USD). Most illegal gold buyers are from Uzbekistan, oth-
ers are Kyrgyz and few are Chinese.
Gold nuggets are frequently found in streams of the Kyrgyz Republic. The largest found so
far weighed 130 gram! It is estimated that the number of gold nuggets recovered per year
larger than ~4 gram exceeds several hundred. Gold nuggets yield much higher price on the
World market than their weight would suggest. The price depends on size and beauty. A
quick survey on the Internet revealed that gold nuggets fetch from 50 Percent of the normal
gold price to 3 times the normal gold price. Gold nuggets are used for jewellery and are
collector's item. Unfortunately do small-scale miners not get better pay for nuggets. Nug-
gets sold to Kyrgyz dealers are apparently melted, but gold sold to Uzbek dealers are sold
as nuggets at high price to buyers in Tashkent.
In some parts of Naryn oblast of central Kyrgyz Republic small-scale miners often find
grains of platinum and osmium in the sluices. Platinum fetch presently a price of about 20
USD per gram and osmium a price of 75 USD on the World market, compared with 11.5
USD per gram on the World market for gold. One gold dealer in Naryn would buy platinum,
but only at the same price as gold, whereas no gold dealer would buy osmium mainly be-
cause they cannot identify the metal.
G E U S
Teaching seminars in Eki-Naryn and Bishkek
During the first mission in May-June the village of Eki-Naryn was visited. This village has
about 150 households and is largely dependent on placer gold mining. It was thus decided
to arrange a teaching seminar in that village in October. It took place 9 October in one of
the classrooms of the local school. Twenty-seven small-scale miners mostly from the vil-
lage, but also some from a nearby village and a single miner from the Balykty-Suu area
west of Naryn. One of the small-scale miners is a geologist who has started a small placer
gold mining enterprise with a little group of men. Other participants in the teaching seminar
were CBF contacts from Naryn who could be teachers in possible future programs.
The seminar lasted from 10 in the morning to 16 in the afternoon and comprised detailed
description of technical and health problems as well as the results of socio-economic in-
vestigation carried out by CBF. Group working in two rounds with the titles: Problems for
small-scale miners and Suggested ways to solve these issues.
There was a very lively discussion and exchange of ideas. The main problems listed in
random order encountered during the first round of group work were:
· Problems in obtaining patent (certificate)
· Lack of knowledge on safety measures
· Lack of proper clothing
· High transportation costs for some small-scale miners from village to mining site
· Fluctuating gold prices
· Lack of basic knowledge of geology
The second round of group work unravelled the following ways in random order to improve
their work as small-scale miners:
· More interest and support from local administration
· Easy access to obtain a certificate
· Handouts explaining different mining techniques
· Training courses lasting one to two weeks comprising on site technical instruction
· Fixed price on gold
· Better medical service in the villages
· Financial support as microcredits for purchase of technical equipment.
A two-day Training workshop was held in Kyrgyzaltin Hotel 14 and 15 October with small-
scale miners from all four investigated areas.
The agenda was along the same lines as the workshop held in Eki-Naryn, but with addi-
tional presentations from local experts in Bishkek on safety measures and on legislative
problems (see sections on health issues and legislation).
There was a very lively discussion and exchange of ideas among the small-scale miners
from different part of the country. The small-scale miner finding platinum and osmium in the
G E U S
Naryn explained the other small-scale miners how these metals looked. Discussions as to
which types of sluices were the best were also carried out.
The small-scale miners also carried out-group work dealing with more specific ideas as to
how much financial support they need and for which purposes. They also discussed which
types of training would be of importance for them. The results are shown in the tables be-
Table 1. List of facilities, technical equipment and other things needed by small-scale
miners (estimated for group of 7 people)
Amount (in som)
Outfit and other facilities
- short ones
- long ones
Set of robes and footwear
Jacket and warm pants
Water proof cape
43100 (1045 USD)
- four-bed (2 p.)
Miner's lanterns (2 pieces)
Dishes (plates, glasses, etc.) for 7 person
Items for everyday use and food (100 som/day = 1 per-
son) for 3 days
70300 (1702 USD)
Small mechanical instruments (3 sets)
16000 (387 USD)
G E U S
Table 2. Training requested by small-scale miners
Law on Mineral Resources
Law on Precious Stones and Precious Metals
Temporary regulation on individual gold mining on the territory of KR
Structure of placer gold deposits, types of placer gold deposits
Methods of exploration and definition of average gold concentration in sands
Estimate of gold resources in deposit
Testing methods of exploring excavations
Methods of gold mining
Equipment used for washing
Instructions on maintenance of geological exploration works in placer gold deposits
Rules of labour protection and safety measures in mining placer gold deposits
Mercury and nitric acid use
Preventive measures of catarrhal and rheumatic diseases
Harmfulness of mercury and other chemicals for the environment
G E U S
Problems faced by small-scale miners and ways to solve them
1. Imperfection of existing laws: Law on Mineral Resources, Law on Precious Stones
and Precious Metals, Temporary Regulation on Small-Scale Mining in KR.
2. Lack of technical equipment to mine gold deposits
3. Lack of knowledge on safety measures in mining.
4. Lack of sources where small-scale miners could get financial support.
5. Lack of opportunity to sell gold legally and for fair price
6. Small-scale miners work in hard-rock deposits illegally
7. Lack of any social guarantees for small-scale miners
Ways to solve problems
1. to make amendments and changes to legislature:
- on regulating and allowing small-scale miners work on licensed territories;
- on creation of market for gold nuggets;
- on opening of gold receipt desks and shops by juridical persons and indi-
viduals where small-scale miners could make orders for necessary products
- on legalisation of small-scale mining in hard-rock gold deposits;
2. to form small co-operatives (Associations) from small-scale miners, and provide
them loans and grants through international organisations and development pro-
3. to organise different awareness programs for small-scale miners (training work-
shops, posters, mass media, booklets, leaflets, etc.) through Community and Busi-
ness Forum (CBF)
G E U S
Videoconference on distance learning courses for
small-scale miners. Bishkek, October 14, 2003.
World Bank Washington, USA:
Welcome and introductory remarks.
Biskek, Kyrgyz Republic:
Vladimir Zubkov, Deputy Director, State Geological Agency of the Kyrgyz Republic: Small
scale mining in the Kyrgyz Republic.
Peter Appel, Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland:
Field investigations of small-scale miners techniques and health problems in the Kyrgyz
Cholpon Dyikanova, Community Business Forum:
Socio-economic assessment of small-scale miners communities in the Kyrgyz Republic.
Usenbek Choponov, geologist, small-scale miner, Eki-Naryn, Naryn oblast: Report on the
outcome of the Training workshop in Eki-Naryn 9 October 2003.
Six small-scale miners presented some of their problems.
Salkyn Niyazova, small-scale miner, Sary-jaz area, Issyk-Kul oblast
I come from Sary-jaz area, which is 200 km from Issyk-Kul oblast centre. I have three chil-
dren, and I am unemployed. And so, I had to find income source to feed my children. My
husband is unemployed too. He is breeding the cattle and also helps me to mine gold to
satisfy our everyday needs. In our mining area there are three more women mining placer
gold in Sary-jaz river. I hope that this videoconference will be very useful for small-scale
miners and officials to understand each other. Thank CBF for organising workshop, which
was very useful for us. And it will be very good if the World Bank will provide financial sup-
port and training courses for small-scale miners like me. Thank you very much.
Abdykadyr Abdrahmanov, small-scale miner, At-Bashy area, Naryn oblast.
I come from At-Bashy. I wash gold in Balyktysuu River. The village where I live is 50 km
from the place where we mine. Here in Bishkek it is warm, but there we have snow. We
work the whole year. We work in placer gold deposit, and sometimes we find nuggets.
There are 8 people in my brigade Last year one of our small-scale miners found a nugget
weighing 43 grams. Peter Appel told us that nuggets are expensive. We did not know it. We
sell nuggets at the same price as alluvial gold. In At-Bashy we also mine platinum and os-
mium, but we don't know where we should sell these metals, because there is no market in
Kyrgyzstan. Peter Appel promised when he'll be back to Denmark he will find buyers for
platinum, osmium and nuggets. We request WB to help us providing grants for stimulation
of small-scale mining. We could get working clothes and technical equipment. Thank you.
G E U S
Nurlan Orozbaev, small-scale miner, Naryn oblast.
Me, Nurlan Orozbaev, is from Eki Naryn village, Naryn oblast. Our village is high up in the
mountain 70 km from Naryn. Climate is very harsh, and winter season lasts 7-8 months.
Under our climatic conditions wheat doesn't grow, and there are no jobs in the village. From
150-170 households in our village about 70% mine gold. This is their main income. Work is
very hard, and we work the whole year. We have lots of problems; we don't have warm
working clothes. One of the most acute problems is maintenance of safety measures in
tunnelling. We work in placer and hard rock gold deposits. Some tunnels are up to 20 me-
ters in length. It is difficult to tell about an accident when my eldest brother died in tunnel
after a rock fall. We don't have materials to support walls in tunnels. On behalf of people
living in my village I ask World Bank to help to acquire materials for supporting walls in tun-
nels, technical equipment for tunnelling and organise training on safety measures. It would
be very good to organise such training in villages so more small-scale miners could partici-
pate. Thank you very much for inviting me.
Bakas Gaparov, small-scale miner, Soh area, Batken oblast
I come from Batken oblast, very remote region, which is densely populated. There is not
enough irrigated land for people. Village households have been allocated the smallest land
shares in Kyrgyz Republic (0.01 hectare per a person), and we can not survive on income
from our land. In my village 95% of people are unemployed, and 87% of them live in pov-
I have started to mine only last year. In Batken there are about 200-300 small-scale miners.
It is small, not so much as in other regions. I think that small-scale gold mining could help
us generate income. I am very thankful for being invited to videoconference and training
workshop for small-scale miners in Bishkek. I have learnt many theoretical and practical
things. When I'll go back home I'll share all knowledge and information gained here. And I
hope that in future the World Bank will pay attention to small-scale miners and their prob-
lems, and help us with grants and loans.
Farhad Satimov, small-scale miner, Chatkal area, Jalal-Abad oblast
I am small-scale miner from Chatkal. There are working more than 3000 small-scale miners
in our area. They are mining placer and hard rock gold deposits. It started in 1995. Our
area has the largest number of small-scale miners, who have good skills on mining, and
also there is biggest number of gold deposits.
One of acute problems faced by small-scale miners in Chatkal is:
- strong need for social guarantees for small-scale miners, i.e. pensions and
other kind of social insurance. Now I am young and I can work all the year
round in cold water. But could I work when I get old? It will be very good to
establish an Association of Small-scale Miners to support us;
- opening of gold-receipt shop. Until last year we had no problems in selling
our gold. Most gold buyers came from neighbouring Uzbekistan. Recently
Uzbekistan introduced strict customs control system, and now it's impossi-
ble to take gold through the frontier posts. Gold price became very low. I re-
quest on behalf of Chatkal small-scale miners to open legal gold receipt
shops with special clothes and equipment for small-scale miners. It will be
very good if WB could help with it.
G E U S
Usenbek Choponov, geologist, small-scale miner, Naryn oblast
Small-scale mining has been carried out in Naryn since 1995. The number of small-scale
miners is increasing year by year. Presently there are about 2000-2500 small-scale miners
in Solton-Sary, At-Bashy, Kichi Naryn. They mine placer and hard-rock gold deposits. The
main reason pushing people to mine gold in our very harsh climatic conditions is unem-
ployment and lack of other means of income. So, gold mining helps people to satisfy basic
needs of their households.
However, they also face many problems such as:
1. Lack of knowledge in geology makes it difficult to find the right places to wash for
2. Many gold deposits are situated far from the villages where the small-scale miners
live such as Kumbel, Solton-Sary, Balyksuu in At-Bashy mining areas. Small-scale
miners have to walk 2-3 days to mining areas because car costs expensive.
3. Lack of legal gold receipt desks. The private gold buyers set price for gold them-
selves sometimes as low as 250-300 som (5 to 6 USD).
4. Lack of knowledge on legislation such as Law on Natural Resources and support-
ing legislative acts. For example, small-scale miners could not work in licensed ar-
eas. Sometimes it appears that many areas with concentration of placer gold de-
posits suddenly have been rented for pasturing, so the land has new owners, who
don't allow small-scale miners to work on their territories.
5. Lack of knowledge on safety measures, which results in many accidents. For ex-
ample, during 2001-2003 three casualties took place in Naryn oblast.
6. Lack of funds to purchase the necessary working clothes, footwear, sleeping bags,
tents, working instruments and so forth. There is also no possibility to mechanise
mining by buying a motor-pump, rock breaker, crushers and etc.
7. Due to harsh working conditions many small-scale miners often have health prob-
lems. At present about 60-70% of youth involved in small-scale mining have rheu-
matism, polyarthritis and other catarrhal diseases.
8. Problems creating co-operatives. One of them is that working out business plan
costs lots of money.
Possible ways to solve problems
1. To organise training courses on basic geology.
2. To organise field training with participation of geologists with demonstration of ad-
vanced technologies applicable for small-scale gold mining.
3. To sell gold to legalised dealers according to World market price.
4. To form co-operatives from 5-10 people with further registration.
5. To have TV and radio programs on small-scale mining issues in Kyrgyz Republic.
Dissemination of special brochures about small-scale mining.
6. Local administration should pay more attention to small-scale mining issues.
7. To improve medical service in villages.
8. To provide financial support to small-scale miners. For example, microcrediting
from international organisations, development programs etc.
Credits will be used:
- to buy or rent technical equipment (excavators, bulldozers and trucks);
- to register co-operatives, work out business plan, and obtain license;
- to buy working clothes, footwear, tents, instruments and small mechanical
equipment (motor-pumps, hammers, etc.)
There is problem in obtaining these credits because most financial institutions require cash
guarantees. Usually village people could suggest their houses, which are built from clay
bricks. And a house constructed from clay bricks could not be used as collateral security.
That's why the only way to solve this problem is leasing, i.e. to get credit in the form of
G E U S
equipment (excavators, bulldozer, truck) that could be at the same time used as financial
Review of outcomes of the workshop on artisanal and small-scale mining in Ghana. Com-
ments from small-scale miners and consultants. Comparing practices of small-scale miners
from Ghana and Kyrgyzstan. Ways of solving problems in Ghana.
University of Alberta
Opinions of specialists on ecological impact of small-scale mining.
What contacts established between technical and educational institutions of Canada and
Kyrgyzstan could be used by small-scale miners.
World Bank, Washington, USA
Summary of the conference outcomes and closing.
G E U S
List of participants
Valentin Bogdetskiy, Adviser to the Prime Minister of the Kyrgyz Republic.
Azimbek Joloshev, Head of Fuel, Energy and Mining Section of Prime-Ministers Apparatus.
Karybek Ibraev, Expert of Fuel, Energy and Mining Section of Prime-ministers Apparatus.
Vladimir Zubkov, Deputy Director of State Geological Agency.
Gennadiy Potapenko, Principal Specialist of State Geological Agency.
Irina Gorshkova, Head of Ecological Monitoring Department of the Ministry of Ecology and
Rozalia Jenchuraeva, Professor, Institute of Geology of the national Academy of Sciences.
Ilya Mesgin, Senior specialist of the Institute of Geology of the national Academy of Sci-
Kamchybek Kojogulov, Deputy Director of Institute of Physics and Mechanics of Rocks.
Gani Abdrasilov, Head of Department of State commission on Business Development.
Vitaly Stavinsky, Executive Director of the Kyrgyz Mining Association.
Institute of Geology of the national Academy of Sciences.
Kapalbek Sultanbekov, Senior Research fellow of Besh-Aral State Reserve.
Farhad Satimov, small-scale miner, Chatkal.
Bakas Gaparov, small-scale miner, Batken.
Kochkonbek Raimbekov, small-scale miner, Chatkal.
Rudbek Abdraev, Inspector of Ecology, Naryn.
Usenbek Choponov, small-scale miner, Eki-Naryn.
Nurlan Onaevroz, small-scale miner, Eki-Naryn.
Abdykadyr Abdrakhmanov, small-scale miner, At-Bashy.
Salkyn Niyazova, small-scale miner, Sary-Jaz.
Pavel Busargin, small-scale miner, Sary-Jaz.
Kenneth Arne, Independent consultant on Minerals, Industrial Marketing, fiscal issues.
Peter Appel, Senior Research scientist, Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland.
Cholpon Dyikanova, Director of Community and Business Forum.